September 12
21.11. - 19.12.2009
When Turkish artist Özlem Sulak, now based in Hanover
and Bremen, came to Germany in 2006 she soon realized that her upcoming work
had to be based on her experience of what it means to be Turkish in Germany.
Having started out in Turkey revisiting the biography of her own family in
order to depict the poignancy of 20th century political and social
history, she now started out to extend her frame to the interactions between
Western and Turkish history. Her work embraces the personal and political in
subtle and equal measures, meaning that all of her filmic works and
installations articulate personal perspective and represent public discourse
while asserting their elemental reciprocity.
Almost 30 years ago, on September 12, 1980, a right-wing military coup
d’état led by General Kenan Evren took state power in Turkey, established
martial law, abolished political parties and trade unions and abolished
democratic rights. Coming after nearly a decade of social and political
conflicts often bordering on civil war, the coup unleashed a wave of repression
against working class and left-wing opponents of the Turkish regime. Up to the
present, life in Turkey is measured by “before” and “after” the coup when
talking about politics, music, art or literature. For her newest video
installation September 12, Sulak
traveled to six Turkish cities, to four towns and two villages in order to
interview a wide spectrum of people who describe what they were doing the day
before the coup and what happened on the morning of the coup. The 12
projections of long, stable shots range from two to seven minutes are shot on
HD. Each shot frames one person in a centralized composition showing them in a
contemplative act through which they recreate the memories of the time. Dilsaz,
a left-wing nurse, talks about how she expected a coup from the left, and how
she soon became totally disenchanted that no opposition was shown; an old lady,
Emine, gives a very personal account, still not knowing now today what really
happened; a former arms dealer, Muharrem, tells how he lost his job after the
coup; and Mustafa, a left-wing radical, speaks about his long time in custody,
reminding us on the fact that during the putsch, one could be imprisoned for up
to 90 days without being charged for a crime.
The singular and very important aspect all interviewees refer to is that they hid their books during the time of the coup
d’état. In a subtle way, this serves as an indication of the severity of the
event: 650,000 people were arrested, 230,000 of those were prosecuted. Seven
thousand of these faced capital punishment. Fifty of them were hung. Another
300 died in unknown circumstances. Another 171 died of torture, while another
300 died in jails. 14,000 were expatriated. 30.000 immigrated to other
countries as political refugees. About 40,000 kg of books and magazines were
burnt. Some of these books are on show in the exhibition space. Except from
progressive Turkish writers like Nazım Hikmet and Aziz Nesin, Marx’s Capital
was banned as well as the writings of Salinger, Orwell, Tolstoy, Hesse, and
Sartre. Somehow these events seem to be written out of history.
The personal accounts range across the spectrum of
society, giving the supporters as well as the opponents of the putsch their
space to express what happened in these days. Sulak concentrates on the
overwhelming intimacy of an individual experience of a singular belonging,
which at large constitutes a fabric of history and its "grand
narrative". There is a strong connection between narrative elements and
her lived experience because self-referentiality is a compelling dimension of
Sulak’s work. Özlem Sulak portrays the turmoil of history as perceived through
a sequence of generations and events that revisit and reconsider paramount
moments of history but also ordinary, insignificant and often forgotten local
cases of private lives and their individual dramas. For her, what happened September
12 affected her family and formed her life. The Coup d'etat not only destroyed
the entire opposition in Turkey and took away the basic liberties with its
oppressive military constitution but also led to more than 20 years of silence.
The biggest fear of the parents of that era who often got jailed was that their
children would somehow get involved with politics. This meant that there would
absolutely be no voicing of political opinion for the generations to come. And
that was Sulak’s generation.
In a second step, Özlem Sulak goes beyond the
situation in Turkey and combines it with the involvement in the West and
especially today’s notion of what is happening in Turkey and whether this
country should be admitted to the EU. In 2008, ARTE stated: “Turkey will become
more liberal and more religious in the upcoming years.” This development is a
direct outcome of September 12 and also of the Western involvement in the case.
The military putsch was done with the help and the silent approval of many European
countries and most significantly the CIA. Officially, the coup was necessary in
order to rehabilitate the bankrupt economy and put an end to “chaos and
anarchy,” something the parliament and government were incapable of doing. But
the situation was far more complex. At the time, Turkish society was divided
between supporters of a free market and a very strong leftist opposition. In
the 1970s Turkey faced chronic economic, social and political instability. The
nationalist policies of building up the country's economy isolated from the
world market had manifestly failed. Successive governments attempted in vain to
solve this problem by relying on more and more foreign loans. But this only
gave Western creditors more leverage to press for “economic restructuring” and
undermine national economic policies. In response, these measures brought the
working class, which experienced explosive growth during the country's
post-World-War II industrialization, into repeated clashes with the economic
and political elite. Moreover, the recurrent economic crises radicalized large
sections of the middle classes, including the peasantry, leading to the
emergence of numerous leftist groups alongside a strong trade union movement.
Faced with this situation, influential leaders of the military and MIT
intelligence service, as well as conservative politicians such as Demirel,
unleashed a systematic terror campaign to weaken left-wing organizations and
pave the way for a coup. The West favored this path because of monetary and geo-strategic
reasons; as a result, they also knowingly supported the introduction of a
fundamentalist Islamism, a far more repressive state and the conflict with the
Kurds and the Alevits. And, ironically, the military constitution of that time
that remains almost unaltered to date revoked the former liberal and democratic
laws that today are demanded by the European Union.
This installation is at first the proof that histories
of human agency and aggression leave consequences, in this case a struggling
and deeply divided Turkey. But at no point does the installation act as an
accusation or take one specific side. The interpretations of September 12th,
1980 are still controversial and Sulak leaves it that way. Sulak’s images
communicate ideals, myths, histories, politics, criticism, ideas, and emotions.
Through thoughtful selection and composition, through intense research of the
context, Sulak exhibits a multifaceted documentary that searches for extended
meanings. This method of judicious withholding encourages viewers to
contemplate the reasons behind the fact of each image, making space for viewers
to formulate their own sense of the situation portrayed.
Özlem Sulak, born 1979 in Kayseri
(TR) lives and works at the Villa
Minimo in Hanover (D). In recent years, she received the grant of the
Kunstverein Hildesheim (2005), the grant of the Künstlerstätte Bleckede (2006)
and the Villa Minimo grant (2008-10). She also has been awarded the fair: Play
’06 Video Festival Award (2006) and the Bremer Videokunstpreis (2008).
Recently, she had a solo show at GAK Bremen (2009) and participated in group
shows at ZKM Karlsruhe, Kunsthaus Graz and Platform Garanti in Istanbul.
For further information please contact the gallery.
